| Year | Captains |
| 1993 | Dave McKelvy |
| 1994 | Matt Rader |
| 1995 | Greg Adams, Jason Craig |
| 1996 | Jeff Faikish, Steve Johnston |
| 1997 | Ryan McGrath, Mike McPeak |
| 1998 | Chris Craig, Steve Phillabaum |
| 1999 | Steve Fleming, Matt Gibson |
| 2000 | Justin Fanslau, Chuck Magee, Justin Kratz |
| 2001 | John Gallagher, Pat Thompson, Matt Williams |
| 2002 | Brett Kratz, Nick Fanslau, Brennan Lodge |